The Crochet Crowd

  • PATTERNS
  • STITCH ALONGS
  • TUTORIALS
  • COMMUNITY & EVENTS
  • ABOUT US
menu icon
go to homepage
  • PATTERNS
  • STITCH ALONGS
  • TUTORIALS
  • COMMUNITY & EVENTS
  • ABOUT US
search icon
Homepage link
  • PATTERNS
  • STITCH ALONGS
  • TUTORIALS
  • COMMUNITY & EVENTS
  • ABOUT US
×
Home » Yarn & Product Reviews

Product Review: Caron Marshmallow Cakes - Highly Surprising

Sharing is caring!

  • Facebook
  • Email

Definitely not for absolute beginners, but totally terrific for ADHD minded people like me. Caron Marshmallow Cakes are a bit of a surprise, even to me, a seasoned crocheter.

I'll admit, some of the colors are pretty trippy, so I found it a bit difficult to choose which color journey I wanted to take. My life is a bit chaotic right now, and I thought I needed something cheerful, bright, and bold for my neutral decor.

Best of all, they also have solid colors of this yarn if the colors are making your brain spin... BUT once I started a pillow face, I realized the colors are pixelated in the most perfect way. That's what surprises me.

Caron Marshmallow Cakes Product Review by Mikey
Caron Marshmallow Cakes Product Review by Mikey
In This Project
  • Try The Pillow Pattern
  • Colour Transitioning
  • Choosing the Right Stitch
  • Chaotic Coloring
  • The Boucle Yarn
  • Yarn Details
  • Show Mikey Your Version of This Project

Try The Pillow Pattern

Test your skills and make the pillow I just made with this yarn. This is the colour choas crochet pillow pattern.

Crochet Colour Chaos Pillow Pattern
Crochet Colour Chaos Pillow Pattern

Colour Transitioning

Usually, when coloring in yarn, we expect something like Red, White and green, and then it restarts again as red, white, and green. It feels like a forced repeat that looks obvious in the pattern. To some, the love it, but for me, depending on the project I don't enjoy that.

Caron Marshmallow Cakes in Sedge Stitchwork
Caron Marshmallow Cakes in Sedge Stitchwork

The colors cycle through, transitioning and doing the opposite effect as they cycle. So it would be red, white, and green... then back to white and red, and so on. So the transitions don't have a definite stopping point.

Choosing the Right Stitch

In crochet samples, it's easy to do rows of single crochet, or whatever, going straight across. However, if you choose different stitches, it can make yarn like this more interesting, as it does on my pillow.

For myself, I considered the crochet sedge stitch and went with it. The primrose stitch would be a second close option for me. The way the stitches play with themselves helps break up the boredom of just a standard back-and-forth stitch.

Take a look at the two tutorials below and let me know what you think. The stitch multiples are given if you like the stitch and want to try it on something else. Even with the darker yarn, the stitch texture, through the bounces of light, reveals itself.

Chaotic Coloring

While the balls look chaotic, know that there is strategy in the way they are dyed. Even if you opt for regular stitches, which is okay too, the colors will still blend, as you can see.

For myself, a 14" pillow doing both faces only takes 1 ball of yarn and a quick evening to make it.

The Boucle Yarn

The yarn has two cores twisted together. You have a strand that is boucle. This is pronounced as 'boo-clay'. It's the short pile of fuzzy yarn you can see. The other core is a standard flat yarn, meaning no fluff projection like regular yarn. It's the boucle that will make it difficult for new crocheters to find the stitches, especially on the beginning chains. However, for people who know what they can see in the chain, it may be slow going across the chain, but then you will get the swing of it, and the rest of the rows or rounds will reveal itself.

Of course, your fingertips to locate stitches are always a plus in crochet.

Caron Marshmallow Cakes Stitched Out on Table with Yarn Left Over
Caron Marshmallow Cakes Stitched Out on Table with Yarn Left Over

Yarn Details

The yarn is a medium #4 weight yarn. It's a mix of 64% nylon and 36" acrylic. It recommends a 6 mm / J/10 crochet hook or 6 mm / US 10 knitting needle.

It is machine washable and dryable; see label instructions for more details on caring for the yarn.

The yarn is 7 oz (200 grams) and 356 yards (325 meters) long.
I have found the yarn 'put out' is generous, and I don't feel I need to overbuy it for it to go the distance.

Caron Marshmallow Cakes Shown as A Cake
Caron Marshmallow Cakes Shown as A Cake

If you get addicted to this yarn, don't blame me. It's a fun one.

More Reviews of Products and Books

  • Yarn Review: Red Heart Super Saver Bitty Batik Yarn
  • What Happens to Acrylic Yarn Outdoors Experiment
  • How Yarn is Made: Spun, Dyed, Packaged & Shipped
  • Product Review: Bernat Blanket Extra Thick with Perfect Phasing

Filed Under: Caron Cakes Yarn Patterns, Yarn & Product Reviews

Comments

    Have you completed this project. Show me! Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    The maximum upload file size: 360 MB. You can upload: image, document. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here

  1. Amy says

    September 28, 2026 at 12:22 am

    Your review is spot on and making a pillow from this plush squishy soft yarn was ideal. I made a sweater with it and am now making many more! i love this yarn and think caron should make this a staple in their line but with rainbow solids, less chaotic color changes. They remind me of the groovy cloud cakes. I want to see these all the time. The yarn is my favorite to work with. I even liked the brown ones and I dislike brown. Apparently not anymore! thanks for the epic review as always!!!

    Reply
Michael Sellick May 2026

Welcome!

I'm Mikey. Join me in learning crochet as I am always learning, too!

More about me
Mikey Stitch Studio Browse Patterns
Yarn Sales with Yarnspirations
Yarn Sales with Yarnspirations
The Crochet Crowd Design

AI Design

Learn about our designs. Why don't we use AI to design?

Designing
  • What is Yarn Worming and Why Would You Care?
  • Crochet All Wrapped Up Batik Shawl Pattern + Tutorial
  • What Are The Yarn Weight Standards?
  • Start to Read Crochet Patterns with 15 Beginner Video Lessons
  • 2 Openwork Crochet Shawls + Tutorials
  • Crochet Round About Blanket Stitch Along with Creative Grandma
  • How to Crochet All In The Family Blanket Pattern + Tutorials
  • Crochet Pineapple Lace Shawl Pattern + Tutorial
  • Crochet Color Chaos Blanket Pattern + Tutorials
  • Crochet Starbean Stitch Throw with 1 Caron Anniversary Cake Ball + Tutorial
  • How To Crochet Sampler Blues Afghan Pattern + Tutorial
  • Mikey Makes: Share Your Ideas
  • Crochet Snowflake Compass Blanket Stitch Along
  • Crochet Study of Staying Put Blanket Stitch Along
See more Crochet Stitch Alongs →

Footer

↑ back to top

Explore

  • About
  • Before 2023
  • 2023 Patterns
  • 2024 Patterns
  • 2025 Patterns
  • 2026 Patterns

More

  • FAQ
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

The website has been active since 2010. Articles and patterns are reviewed from time to time. Some patterns get updated with newly written instructions, photography and keeping the patterns current.

Copyright © 2026 The Crochet Crowd • Some links may contain affiliate connections.