Reading Time: 8 minutes
Wool Comparisons
Wool Comparisons

The Difference in Wool

Have you been to a yarn shoppe and you look at the price of wool and your breathe gets taken away with the price? You see an elevated price and think, “Is there gold mixed into it?” 

Look, I’m an everyday yarn user. I love sales. The cheaper the better and for me walking into an exclusive luxury yarn shop is like walking into a forbidden place. That’s just the type of crocheter I am. No one should apologize for being this type of yarn user as statistically, over 50% of us use everyday yarns found in main retailers.

Wool keeps you warmer as it’s natural insolation that our ancestors used and plays a strong factor. Here in Canada, my winter hats contain wool.

Value to Product
Value to Product

Questions

So I asked an expert recently to tell me the difference between the claims of wool on a product. I had simple questions:

  1. Why is that some wool blends are more expensive than others?
  2. Why can two products of similar weight claim to have 100% wool but are significantly different in price?

The answers back came in two major answers. It comes down to geography and processing of the wool.

Car Wash
Car Wash

The Processing of Wool is Like A Car Wash

When you go to an automatic car washing station, you usually get a choice. The quick scrub and a rinse to the gold package of extra scrub, under spray and even polishing. They are always a difference price, unless they have sale, of course.

So the more you want to be done to your car, the more money you will pay. The processing of wool is the same analogy, the more they do, the more they charge.

Sheep
Sheep

The Raising of Sheep to Create Wool

Sheep, of course, is a creature that needs things for survival. They need food, shelter and additional care when needed.

While some sheep naturally shed like Bighorns, other domestic sheep like Merino Sheep, their wool will continuously grow. In extreme cases where they are unable to get cut, they can entomb themselves into death with overheating and restrictive ability to walk. It’s almost a sick joke of mother nature that a creature needs human intervention to live.

Shetland Chunky Yarn
Shetland Chunky Yarn

In some breeds, a sheep is sheared once a year, in other breeds, twice a year. Sheep coats can be between 2 – 18 pounds depending on the sheep. Let’s take a look at Patons Shetland Chunky Yarn.

Comparing Blends of Yarns

Shetland Sheep’s coat only weighs between 2 – 4 lbs. This means you have to raise a lot of Shetland Sheep to make up the difference of other types of sheep that have bigger coats.

This yarn is 25% wool with a mix of acrylic and viscose. The price is $7.49. If this was 100% wool. The yarn price could be as high as $30 per ball. One sheep could only make 48 of these balls. If you add back the acrylic mix, one sheep can make approximately 192 balls. Thus lowering the price back to $7.49.

Usually, independent retailers cater to more naturally based fibres or higher mixes of natural fibres. Thus, in an independent yarn shop, $30 – $40 for a 100% wool product of this size is reasonable.

Rose Thorns
Rose Thorns

The Processing of Wool

What generates the most changing in price is the process by which the wool is processed. Under the microscope, wool looks like the stems of roses. Prickly to the touch. Daniel refers to these as barbs, like barb wire. 

These serve a purpose but also create the irritation of skin to wool touch.

If you have ever been to a historical interpretation site like an old village where the staff is dressed up to recreate the illusion of the past, you may notice the people preparing wool to be spun. You will notice they put the wool onto some brushes and brush the wool. They do it so quickly at these places that yes, they are creating yarn, but they not creating quality yarn. I’ll explain.

  1. Wool needs to be brushed to align the wool fibres in the same direction so it can be spun together. So at the interpretation sites, they are just doing that process quickly as a demonstration. However, in a real-life situation, the brushing is far more rigorous and calculated by machines to do it.
  2. The brushing causes the barbs to peel off. However, the barbs are so small that it takes several passes and layers of brushes to peel them off. The more process it needs, the higher the cost of the final yarn.
Sheep
Sheep

Sheep Breeds

The sheep breeds play a strong factor in the quality of the yarn. Like us humans, we are not all the same. Sheep are the same way because of the level of barbs that are on their wool fibres. Also, sheep that are sheared twice a year are more valuable as their wool is considered fresher and cleaner than sheep that are releasing their wool just once a year.

When certain breeds of sheep are used which increases the prices, it’s usually labelled on the package of what type of sheep’s wool is in the product. It’s the difference of having just a generic sheep versus a specialty sheep.

If I told you my hat was a wool hat versus telling you it’s a Merino wool hat. For those who understand wool, you automatically know the Merino is more valuable and I most likely paid more for the yarn or finished item I bought.

The Crochet Crowd Yarn Studio
The Crochet Crowd Yarn Studio

Mass Retailers Dilemma

In big-box retailers, due to trying to be the best pricing possible on most things. There’s a race to the bottom of the dollar figures to get things to be as cheap as possible. Thus, you generally have a choice of types of yarns to buy. For myself, I’ve learned over the years that yarns are not equal to each other.

There isn’t anything wrong with yarn that is as cheap as possible. However, you get what you pay for. There is a market for the cheapest yarns to the most elaborate yarns on the shelf. I’ve come to understand that usually, the retailers will be inline to the true costs of a product.

So you have a 100% Acrylic Ball sitting beside a Fibre Blended Ball. Both are the same size ball and the fibre blend can be up to double the price. It’s because they are not equal products.

I remember when Caron Cakes came out and still see people complaining today when they cross compare Caron Cakes to Bernat POP!.

Caron Cakes - Spice Cake

Caron Cakes has 20% wool used in the product. They ran testing of the type of yarn before it ever went out to the public.

  1. They tried it with adding more wool to the product. It increased pricing.
  2. They tried it with subtracting more wool out of it and it changed the colour dying and thickness of the yarn.
  3. They tried eliminating out wool completely which took away from the volume of the yarn strand.

After significant testing, it was determined to put in 20% wool and commit to the wool being inside the product.

Wool takes to the dyes differently than acrylic. It can be deeper tones and really give a rich look to the fibre. It also increased the thicknesses to yarn strands. Giving thicker volume.

Patons Classic Wool Worsted
Patons Classic Wool Worsted

Why Do Some Wool Felt and Others Don’t?

Generally speaking, all wool will felt in its natural state. The barbs on the fibres are responsible for the wool felting. The more barbs, the more it will felt. You can have different levels of wool such as Merino and more that will felt up if it’s activated by hot water and agitation. It’s why these types of yarn require you to hand wash.

When fibres are mixed with other fibres, it reduces the number of barbs on the fibre as other fibres don’t have that. Items like Caron Cakes will not felt because the mix of wool is too low for that to happen.

Happy Felted Flower Bag Final Look 2
Happy Felted Flower Bag Final Look 2

The hot water and agitation open up the fibres and the barbs release from each other. The agitation causes the barbs to snag each other and blow up the wool shaping. It causes up to 50% shrinkage.

The manufacturers will reduce the amount of wool in a product to prevent the felting action to happen. However, they can force it not to felt as well.

DK Super Wash is 100% Wool but will not felt. The name of the product tells you why. The wool has been treated to a special wash to remove off most of the barbs that are on the wool. Removing the barbs removes the option for your yarn to felt when washed. In fact, you can even machine wash the DK Super Wash and it will not felt.

What Causes the Itch

Rash
Rash

Medically speaking, an allergy to wool is very rare. It’s not impossible and some people are legitimately allergic but most people itch due to the quality of the wool.

The less the wool is brushed during processing, the coarser the wool will be. This means, there are more barbs left onto the fibre.

Skin sensitivity to the barbs on the wool that catches onto our skin to create the rash. It’s essentially the wool scratching your skin. Many assume it’s because they are allergic, it’s caused by the irritation of the fibre.

The breed of sheep plays a factor for the number of barbs on the fibre but it’s mostly the processing of the fibres to remove most of the barbs. The more barbs that are moved, the more the fibre was processed and the less likely you will be impacted.

When Caron Cakes came out, some automatically assumed they were allergic as it stated wool. Others who claimed to have wool allergies didn’t react as they don’t really have allergies, the wool was processed more removing more barbs making it less likely to irritate their skin. Of course, we each have our own individual sensitivities.

Value to Product
Value to Product

Final Conclusion

I learned a lot in asking simple questions and coming to realize that name wool is a general term. The quality of the wool depends on the sheep. The processing plays a strong factor in final pricing. I’m not allergic to wool myself but I will itch if the wool isn’t processed enough. The only yarn that made me itch at Yarnspirations was Patons Colorwul. It’s since discontinued.

For me, the independent yarn shops are a necessity of life. While the yarn may not make you itch, the pricing could be the cause of it. Knowing there’s a difference in levels of wool puts into perspective costs.

For me, I don’t use the term that wool or independent yarn shops are expensive. They are offering a calibre of product levels that go beyond the typical big-box retailers. They have a place and now I know. It’s just for me to determine if I spend $5 to make a hat or between $20 – $30 to make one. The difference on how wool retains heat and my needs plays the ultimate decision for me.

10 thoughts on “What’s The Difference in Wool?

  1. I really enjoyed your article on wool. I never really considered all that went into the creating of yarn with a wool content. I just accepted that shopping at an independent yarn vendor was a special treat! I truly enjoy your website. Your tutorials are fantastic. Both have encouraged me to expand my horizons and learn different stitches and styles of crochet, as well as the history behind them. Thanks for making crochet, something I truly enjoy, even more enjoyable! P.S. Your SAL and CAL are so much fun! Thanks to you and your team for all you do!

  2. I did not realize how many breeds of sheep and types of wool there are. I have tried marino, but i would like to try others. I have seen yarns that say highland wool, shetland, peruvian. Is it region or breed the wool is from?

  3. Once again you manage to go above and beyond what you expect from someone willing to help you learn about crocheting or anything else for that matter
    Linda Kelly

  4. You are such a plethora of awesome information! Thanks for this <3 btw….that sheep looks like it has something to say LOL

  5. Dear Sir … Thank you again for this enlightenment on the difference in wool and also very instructive for those who do not know about the wool process .. to me I see a big difference in wool when knitting or crocheting a scarf or toque for the harsh winters we have here in Quebec. And also the durability of it and as for the price goes .. well .. I think that if you want to gift someone with something you’re done or created from your own hands I think it’s the perfect choice for it is durable. I’ve been in many sheep farms where they produce wool from Scotland to Ireland to Nova Scotia and PEI and it is indeed great work done by artisans to produce the most quality in their wool .. all have a different approach and techniques but in the end the product is like no other. Again thank you very much for this great article.♥

  6. This is a great article.
    You explain very well what I’m asked all the time.
    I’m a spinner and fiber artist.
    When I buy someone else’s hand spun merino or go to a yarn store I know that I’m going to pay more to get the quality that I want for my project.
    I’ll gladly pay 20 to 30 dollars for a skein to make something beautiful.
    Lace weight and fingering weight is pretty much impossible to get in the box stores.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.